American restaurants

Broadway Cafe Butler

4.2 374 reviews 6:00 AM - 8:00 PM 223 S Broadway St, Butler, IN 46721, United States

Discover this place

Broadway Cafe is a classic American restaurant located at 223 S Broadway St in Butler, Indiana. The cafe offers a wide range of traditional American dishes that cover breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Its menu features hearty options such as corned beef hash, buffalo chicken sandwiches, BBQ ribs, and a variety of omelets, along with comfort foods like mashed potatoes and gravy. Signature items include toasted breakfast sandwiches served with bacon, sausage, or ham, and several a la carte sides. The atmosphere at Broadway Cafe reflects a straightforward, local dining experience with a focus on familiar flavors and generous portions. The restaurant’s diverse menu caters to a variety of tastes and mealtime preferences, maintaining a balance between homestyle cooking and casual dining. This approach has positioned Broadway Cafe as a steady choice for residents and visitors seeking uncomplicated American fare in a relaxed setting.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service
Great coffee
Serves local specialty

Popular for

Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Quiet

Crowd

Groups

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Broadway Cafe Butler before visiting.

Reviews for Broadway Cafe Butler

4.2

374 reviews

100%

55%

23%

Review highlights

Based on 374 reviews

Broadway Cafe in Butler, IN, is praised for its flavorful American cuisine, especially breakfast offerings like skillets, French toast, and signature sandwiches such as Reubens. Customers commonly highlight the quality and taste of the food, noting a satisfying and well-prepared menu that caters to diverse cravings. The cafe's atmosphere is described as inviting, making it a favored spot for casual dining, coffee, and pie. However, service experiences appear mixed; while some patrons commend attentive and friendly staff, others report slow or inconsistent wait times and occasional difficulties in receiving prompt attention. Despite these occasional service delays, the recent changes under new ownership, including updated menus and kitchen staff, have been received positively, signaling an overall improvement in the restaurant’s appeal and dining experience.

Jessi Ogg

May 14, 2025

I'll start by disclosing I'm pregnant and having strong cravings! This food 100% met my expectations. I ordered a garbage skillet with eggs over easy and boy, was it delicious! I got a side of yummy raisin toast with it which was toasted to perfection & already buttered! Also ordered a side of French toast which was also made perfectly. My taste buds were very pleased! Highly recommend. The only slightly negative observation of my order was the coffee was pretty weak, too much water. Overall, I was still very happy with my meal & will definitely be ordering more in the future.

Jessica Stroh

May 08, 2025

Great food. Friendly staff. We didn’t see our server again until long after we finished the meals.

Michael Meisener

Apr 27, 2025

New owners, this place rocks, new menus and cooks. Great place for a cup of coffee and pie

Eleni 1979

Apr 16, 2025

Their ruebens are absolutely phenomenal! That said this would be the third weekend in a row that we have come to Broadway Cafe on a Saturday or Sunday morning and they have not been busy, but we have waited for at least 10 minutes before anybody has bothered coming up to wait on us- today it was 15 minutes, no sign of the waitress so I got up walked up to the counter paid for my coffee and walked out.

Travis Miller

Apr 12, 2025

Our server Kennedybwas amazing! Super sweet and very fast!

Tamara Mathers

Apr 02, 2025

Will be our go to place for Breakfast for now on. Big helpings ,hot and tasty! Waitress was very busy,by herself yet very attentive!Thank You!

James Frybarger Jr

Mar 31, 2025

Good food great price. Service was fast and polite.

Shawnee Likes

Mar 20, 2025

Beef and noodles a little darker than normal. But I got there later in the eve.